FIONA kernel test against Airy disc simulation

This is the result of a simulation of a single-point fluorophore emitter, using an Airy disc simulator program. Common settings for all of the tests include: Aperture 500nm, wavelength 510nm, Pixel spacing 70nm, 0.1 of the pixels hidden by the borders, 40000 fluorescent photons, 20 photons per count, 256 samples/pixel in X and Y. Test1: no Poisson noise, no dark current. Test2: with Poisson noise, no dark current. Test3: with Poisson noise, 1000 dark photons per pixel dark current.

Test 1: FIONA kernel

Poisson Noise
Dark Current
Mean Radial Error
Mean X Error
Mean Y Error
Max Radial Error
X Bias
Y Bias
Estimates/Sec
True Log
Tracking Log
Images
nonoise
nodark
0.0019494
0.00112207
0.00144554
0.00451355
0.000189574
0.000110656
44.1365
Log
VST Log
Images
noise
nodark
0.0116194
0.00803434
0.00668287
0.026351
0.00107008
0.000510902
38.763
Log
VST Log
Images
noise
1kphotons
0.0158757
0.0112974
0.00885879
0.0292512
0.00139034
0.002416
37.1479
Log
VST Log
Images

Example images follow:

airy_nonoise_nodark.000.bmp

airy_noise_nodark.000.bmp

airy_noise_1kphotons.000.bmp

Test 2: Symmetric kernel

Poisson Noise
Dark Current
Mean Radial Error
Mean X Error
Mean Y Error
Max Radial Error
X Bias
Y Bias
Estimates/Sec
True Log
VST Log
Images
nonoise
nodark
0.00215877
0.00132769
0.00146223
0.00589521
-0.000418738
0.000510918
56.11
Log
VST Log
Images
noise
nodark
0.0103172
0.00714351
0.00602611
0.0231526
0.000365705
0.000927197
52.9385
Log
VST Log
Images
noise
1kphotons
0.0147961
0.0103369
0.00828923
0.0287145
0.00049377
0.00252805
55.2306
Log
VST Log
Images

Example images follow:

airy_nonoise_nodark.000.bmp

airy_noise_nodark.000.bmp

airy_noise_1kphotons.000.bmp